My cats are extremely spoiled, and very picky when it comes to both toys and treats, so I usually don't do the subscription boxes for them anymore because it ends up being a waste of money. I gave this one a shot because it's new, and I saw the ad for the October Halloween box, plus a percentage gets donated. I have 3 black cats and we go all out for Halloween, so this months box is their Halloween present. From the moment I walked in the door with the box, my cats went crazy, all three of them. I could hardly get the box open because the three of them kept standing on it and pawing at it trying to get it open. When I did finally get it open, they immediately each claimed their toy. They are very different when it comes to what they'll each play with, and like I said, they are extremely picky about what they'll play with. Emily grabbed the crinkle pumpkin, Thackery took the broom stick, and Binx got the ghost. They've been taking turns sitting in the box, and the most shocking part of all for me.....all three of them loved the treats. I've had my babies since they were each 3 months old (the boys are 5 and Emily is 4), and I have only found one other treat that all 3 of them will eat. I'm keeping my fingers crossed that next months box and just as much of a hit!